Lire cet article en français / Read this article in French
The midterm elections dealt a major blow to Trump and the Republicans, with a massive blue wave (blue being the Democratic Party’s color) resulting in Democrats gaining control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate.
While midterms are traditionally difficult for the president’s party, the Democratic victory was spectacular. In 2018, Democrats outpolled Republicans nationwide by 8 points, while Republicans had beaten Democrats by 4 points in 2022. In 2026, the Democratic lead reached 12 points, translating into massive gains in House seats and Senate victories in unlikely states such as Iowa, Ohio, Texas and Kansas.
Although the cost of living and corruption were the two issues most frequently cited by voters as their top priorities, Israel emerged as a related concern, both because of the role of the war in Iran in driving up prices and because of the perceived influence of Israel in triggering that war.
As discussed in Tenoua last March, “The overwhelming support for this war among Republicans, following some initial hesitation, primarily reflects their almost automatic loyalty to Trump. Should this war go badly tomorrow, there is little doubt that America First would come roaring back. And in a party where 45% of those under 45 believe that Jews threaten the American way of life, one can only imagine where their anger would be directed…”
Following the Republicans’ disastrous results, the war in Iran is indeed now being singled out as an explanation by the America First wing of MAGA. Vice President JD Vance, who hopes to take up that mantle ahead of his highly likely 2028 presidential campaign, has called for a profound reassessment of the alliance with Israel. His remarks sent shockwaves and triggered a debate in both Israel and the United States, particularly since the issue is already weighing heavily on the Democratic Party, under pressure from its left wing, which on this point finds itself aligned with the Republican Party’s right wing.
Yet the Israel‐Palestine issue, an important component of identity politics, played a less prominent role in these midterms than it did in the 2024 elections, held in the midst of the Gaza war. The 2026 vote was dominated instead by concerns over the cost of living. Nevertheless, the election presents a paradoxical opportunity to fundamentally rethink and normalize the Israeli‐American relationship, which should once again become a foreign policy issue like (almost) any other. In this respect, Trump’s announcement that he wanted to end military assistance to Israel, made on the day of the midterms, could help prevent the Jewish state from remaining the central and divisive issue in American politics that it has become.
The need to remove Israel from the realm of American domestic politics is all the more urgent given that the Jewish state’s popularity has declined sharply, not only among Democrats but also among younger Republicans. More than 60% of Americans now have an unfavorable opinion of Israel, including nearly 80% of Democrats, 77% of whom believe that Israel has committed “genocide” in Gaza. Nearly 40% of Republicans, and 50% of Republicans under 50, also hold an unfavorable view. JD Vance’s criticism of Israel was therefore as sincere as it was calculated, signaling a genuine shift in tone on the right.
For the State of Israel, which for years had been lulled by the illusion of unconditional, across‐the‐board bipartisan support in Washington, before being led by its prime minister into an alignment with the Republicans, the wake‐up call has been brutal. It should prompt a fundamental reassessment of its relationship with the United States. This issue was also raised during Israel’s recent election campaign by the leading opposition figures, who understand that this loss of support represents a profound threat to the Jewish state.
The need for a change of government is, of course, urgent when it comes to domestic policy. But Netanyahu’s departure would also be welcome in order to allow the relationship with the United States to be rebuilt on healthier foundations. After systematically sabotaging ties with the Democratic Party, Netanyahu has now become persona non grata there, even among Democrats who have traditionally been pro‐Israel. Among Republicans, his openly acknowledged role in triggering the war in Iran has also made him politically toxic. In both parties, his arrogance, brutality and lies have ultimately become deeply irritating, particularly given that he is highly unpopular with the American public, making him a liability for elected officials, Republicans included.
Netanyahu’s departure, necessary and urgent as it may be, will not in itself be enough to rebuild a more constructive relationship. Faced with an American public that has now turned against Israel, even though this issue did not drive its voting decisions, Democratic lawmakers who hold a majority in Congress will demand significant changes regarding violence in the Palestinian territories, the expansion of settlements and the implementation of Trump’s plan for Gaza. They may even call for the reversal of some of the measures Netanyahu introduced as part of his judicial overhaul.
They will be all the more inclined to do so because these priorities are widely shared by American Jews, as demonstrated by a recent poll. It found that only 20% have a favorable opinion of Netanyahu, down from 32% in 2024 ; just 30% support unconditional military assistance to Israel ; 80% believe that Israel’s actions in Gaza and the West Bank fuel antisemitism ; and 76% favor sanctions against individuals or ministers linked to settler violence in the West Bank.
Many American Jews believe that this “special” relationship has ultimately provided anti‐Zionists and antisemites with an attack line against both Israel and American Jews that is as insidious as it is effective, precisely because of its divisive nature. The occupation and the country’s illiberal drift have also contributed to creating a schism between American Jews and Israel, at a time when antisemitism is rising sharply. Two fundamental pillars of American Jewish life are therefore now being called into question : their physical security and their attachment to a country in which they increasingly struggle to recognize themselves. Beyond the diplomatic dimension, a new relationship between Israel and the United States is therefore also essential to the very unity of the Jewish people, bringing together its two largest communities.
The famous line from Lampedusa’s The Leopard — “If we want things to stay as they are, things will have to change” — is particularly apt when it comes to the relationship between the United States and Israel. For this relationship to endure and prosper, it must undergo profound change. The arrival of a new Congress and potentially new leadership in Israel offer an opportunity to rebuild it on healthier and more balanced foundations, allowing the Jewish state to turn the page on the Netanyahu era and strengthen an alliance that remains indispensable to its security, provided it makes certain substantive and stylistic adjustments to its policies.




